Loading... Please wait...

Blog

Esteemed medical journal bans term “tobacco products” from vaping studies

Posted by

Scientists from around the world often publish research studies in a variety of fields on the highly regarded medical journal Nicotine & Tobacco Research (NTR). Last month, its Editor-in-Chief Marcus Munafò made the remarkable but somewhat controversial announcement that the organization will no longer allow publications of studies that refer to vaping technology and e-liquids as tobacco products. The announcement is receiving high praise from advocates within the vaping community who have long refuted use of the term by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) as a guideline to implement overly harsh regulations that threaten to bankrupt the entire industry by 2022.

Taking a stand in favor of vaping

The move was made public in an opinion piece authored by Munafò and published on the Oxford Academic website on June 20. The article entitled Are e-cigarettes tobacco products suggests that even though the FDA insists of labeling both tobacco-free vaping devices and combustible tobacco products into the same category, the scientific community is smart enough to make clear the discernable differences between the two.

“Our preference is for the term ‘tobacco products’ to be reserved for those products that are made from and contain tobacco (rather than contain constituents such as nicotine extracted from it). The term ‘nicotine-containing products’ is more general, and can be applied to tobacco products but also non-tobacco products such as e-cigarettes and nicotine replacement therapies. However, even the term nicotine-containing products does not apply to cases where aerosol-producing devices are used with liquids that do not contain nicotine – in this case distinguishing between vaping devices and liquids (which may or may contain nicotine) could be helpful.”

Munafò also seems to take issue with a couple of other terms, as well. For example, he suggests that authors of published vaping studies should avoid calling vaping devices ENDS or Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems. After all, not every vaping device is electronic, and not all e-liquids are infused with nicotine. The rise in popularity of zero-nicotine e-liquids makes the use of the term only more confusing for the general public and can easily be viewed as intentionally misleading.

“Another common description is electronic nicotine-delivery systems (ENDS), but again this is potentially problematic because not all devices are electronic (and again may deliver liquids that do not contain nicotine). A simpler approach would therefore be to refer to ‘cigarettes’, ‘e-cigarettes’ and so on, without reference to broad categories. The exception would be cases where e-cigarettes are being referred to in a specific policy context (e.g., in relation to the FDA). The guiding principle is that the terminology used should be clear, unambiguous, and scientifically appropriate.”

Editor-in-Chief Marcus Munafò seems to be taking a very courageous stance by insisting that the scientific community do its part to responsibly educate the general public regarding vaping versus smoking. He calls this obsession to identify vaping devices and e-liquids as tobacco products an American phenomenon, and one that is not consistent throughout the global scientific community. 

View Comments


FDA approves first marijuana-based drug Epidiolex for epilepsy patients

The marijuana-based prescription medication Epidiolex has just received FDA approval and might be available as early as this fall to patients suffering from two forms of severe epilepsy. The medication manufactured by the London-based company GW Pharmaceuticals is designed to reduce or prevent the number and severity of grand mal seizures commonly associated with Lennox-Gastaut and Dravet syndromes of epilepsy.These [...]

Read More »


Rasta Vapors launches 50% Off Customer Appreciation Sale on all e-liquids

With vaping regulations under attack in nearly every region of the United States and beyond, Rasta Vapors is pleased to announce a 50% Off Customer Appreciation Sale on all e-liquids. We have the most loyal community of regular customers, and we feel that it’s time to express our gratitude by slashing prices on over 35 mouthwatering brands. Every [...]

Read More »


Vaping study shows no negative health effects to lung surfactant

Recent surveys show that an overwhelming number of Americans mistakenly believe that vaping is just as hazardous to one’s health as smoking. As misinformation about vaping spreads across social media like wildfire, a new study out of Ohio University shows that vaping does not damage the lung surfactant to any measurable degree. Smoking, on the other [...]

Read More »


Canada makes history by legalizing marijuana, medical and recreational

With the passage of Bill C-45 last Tuesday by the Canadian parliament, Canada becomes only the second country in the world to legalize marijuana for both medical and recreational use. The new legislation follows the legal precedent set forth by Uruguay which no longer prohibits the possession, sales, and growing of cannabis products.Underage use is still against the [...]

Read More »


American Cancer Society sides with vaping as a smoking cessation aid – finally!

As the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) maintains a consistent attack on the vaping industry, public health organizations like the American Cancer Society (ACS) have remained somewhat noncommittal. Meanwhile, organizations like the American Lung Association are guilty of spreading misinformation alleging that vaping is a gateway to smoking, especially among teens. Others attempt to delay their opinions [...]

Read More »


Judge accuses Florida officials of ‘colossal blunder’ regarding marijuana licenses

When the state of Florida voted to legalize medical marijuana in late 2016, many thought the war was finally over. Little did they know that the fight for prescription cannabis was only just beginning.As physicians began writing prescriptions for patients suffering from chronic and sometimes life-threatening ailments who could benefit positively from the new law, cracks in the [...]

Read More »


Research shows vaporized propylene glycol kills streptococci bacteria

Scientific research dating as far back as the 1940s shows that the vaporized propylene glycol commonly found in the e-liquids of vaping products may have some secret positive public health benefits. A world-class scientist by the name of Dr. Theodore Puck discovered that when this ingredient is heated to approximately 800 degrees Fahrenheit, it kills numerous forms of [...]

Read More »


FDA’s Scott Gottlieb ‘disappointed by tepid response’ of vaping industry

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is in the midst of a federal probe regarding the marketing of kid-appealing e-liquids. With a new 30-day extension recently announced, the deadline to submit comments is now July 16, 2018. Meanwhile, the head of the government agency is expressing his disappointment regarding the vaping industry’s apparent lack of concern [...]

Read More »


Last chance for comments: FDA probe on vaping ban ends in only 2 weeks!

If you haven’t yet commented on the FDA probe seeking public input regarding a possible vaping ban on flavored e-liquids, then what are you waiting for? The 90-day probe officially ends on June 19, about two short weeks away. Anyone can leave a comment, and you can even leave multiple responses, if you like. The time to [...]

Read More »


Sign up for our newsletter

View Cart Go To Checkout